This
issue of INFORMATION FOR SOCIAL SCIENTISTS leads with the
latest on the spiraling prices of journals. As consumers
and producers of scholarly information, make sure you are
aware of these issues which affect us all. On a happier note,
you'll find updated information on the library building program
and news about changes in microforms that will make using
that format easier. The Electronic Data Center has an update
for the number crunchers among you and many of you
will find additional library staff in the social sciences
to help you. As usual we include Electronic Update
with the latest resources of interest to social scientists.
This includes important changes to the ERIC educational
system.
It's also time for advanced graduate students to consider
applying for Woodruff Fellowships in the library. Earn
money, finish your dissertation and learn valuable new skills!
Don't miss out! Comments? Suggestions? Contact Liz McBride,
ISS Editor, at 7 6953 or libemb@emory.edu.
CRISIS IN SCHOLARLY PUBLICATION
CONTINUES
Are publishers getting rich publishing your research? A Bear
Stearns evaluation of ReedElsevier (one of the world's largest
publishers of scholarly journals) recently rated the company,
which earns profits of almost 40% annually, "a stockholder's
dream." Should private publishers be getting rich selling
information generated by research that is funded by academic
institutions and the public? What's happening and how does
it affect scholars at Emory?
The Problem
In
an article published here in 2001, we reported that Emory
was paying $17,444 for an annual subscription
to Brain, a
multidisciplinary journal devoted to fundamental research
in brain sciences. That same subscription costs $21,269 today.
Journal prices have not come down. The price increases have
been constant and alarming. According to data collected by
the Association of Research Libraries (ARL), during the 15
year period between 1986 and 2001, scholarly journal prices
jumped 215 per cent although the Consumer Price Index rose
by just 64 percent. Journal prices actually grew twice as
fast as health care costs during this period. The arrival
of electronic journals has not stopped this trend. In fact,
many publishers have been "bundling" their electronic
journals, forcing libraries to subscribe to many titles at
once to have any significant dollar savings.
Top tier journals continue to be concentrated in the hands
of a relatively small group of commercial publishers. The
top six companies now publish about 4,000 journals. This
concentration drives up prices. Elsevier Science, the publishing
arm of the Reed Elsevier Group, is the largest publisher
with over 1800 titles and some of the highest costs. Many
of the Elsevier titles are in the social sciences: International
Journal of Educational Research ($1292), Journal of Criminal
Research ($914), Journal of Econometrics ($2463), Personality
and Individual Differences ($2018) and Social Science And
Medicine ($4174). World Development, an Elsevier title which
cost about $250 in 1997, now costs $1887. In a time of tight
university budgets, a crisis is building.
The continuing increase in journal pricing has led many
academic institutions to boycott selected publishers. Harvard,
Cornell and the University of California system have announced
that they would no longer subscribe to Elsevier's ScienceDirect
electronic journal service because of price increases and
bundling requirements. In one of the latest developments,
the provosts of Duke, North Carolina State and UNC Chapel
Hill have announced that the Triangle Research Libraries
Network (TRLN) will also end their consortial contract with
ScienceDirect. One consequence of this move will be the loss
of electronic access to the body of titles shared throughout
TRLN. It is estimated that access to 400 500 electronic titles
will be lost on each campus beginning this month.
While
Elsevier figures prominently in discussions on serial price
increases, the problem is widespread and
impacting
numerous disciplines. In a recent article entitled "The
Rise and Rise of Journal Prices in African Studies," author
Hans Zell, writes that subscription prices for the 13 leading
African Studies journals published in English have been sky
rocketing. African Studies (Oxford University Press) has
gone from $67 in 1997 to $230 in 2002/2003. Review of African
Political Economy (Taylor & Francis), has gone from $190
in 1997 to $420 last year. It was only $28 in 1989!
Thrown into the mix is the decision of many publishers to
begin charging for electronic copies of journals that used
to be free with print subscriptions. Oxford University Press
is the latest example of this trend.
The net results of escalating journal costs on university
libraries are journal cancellations, decisions to stop duplicating
formats (print or electronic), and spending less money on
monographs.
At
the University of Georgia, the University Librarian recently
issued an open letter to all faculty
notifying them that
the Library would be converting all subscriptions held in
print and electronic formats to online only. He also reported
that this was a "stopgap measure" and UGA would
be forced to cancel journal titles in the coming years.
Journals at Emory
Researchers at Emory have generally been lucky. The General
Libraries have had reasonable budget increases and our consortial
contract for Elsevier's electronic journals was negotiated
early in 2003 at fairly favorable terms that will remain
in effect until 2006. Still our budgets cannot keep up with
current price escalations and the General Libraries have
begun advocating the purchase/licensing of electronic over
print whenever possible. It is no longer possible to pay
twice for various formats of the same title.
Unlike the General Libraries, Emory's Health Sciences Library
has had a flat budget for several years. This is in effect
a budget cut since there are no funds to cover increases
in journal costs. Continuing journal cancellations have resulted
and the General Libraries has reallocated some of its own
funds to cover costs for selected science and medical journals
used throughout the campus.
Possible Solutions
As a reaction to the growing crisis in scholarly communication,
new models for information dissemination are beginning to
appear. Open access is the most revolutionary of these. In
open access, publications are free for all users anywhere
in the world and are archived permanently in wellestablished
online repositories. Costs are paid by universities, foundations,
federal agencies or others. Open access journals are primarily
online journals. This allows authors to include audio, video,
data sets, etc. as a part of their articles. Online publication
also means that information reaches users in a more timely
manner. Open access initiatives include:
• Public
Library of Science (PLoS) is a non profit initiative to
publish open access journals
led by nobel laureate
and former director of the NIH, Harold Varmus. Its first
goal, to publish a top tier peer reviewed science journal
that will compete with titles such as Science, Nature, and
Cell, was accomplished in October 2003 with the launch of
PLoS Biology. PLoS plans to publish other open access journals
in the future. (www.plos.org)
• BioMed Central publishes more than 100 peer reviewed open
access journals and hosts independent open access journals.
Emory is an institutional member of BioMed Central which
means that Emory authors can waive the article processing
fees when they submit articles to BioMed Central journals.
• Independent journals, often started by academics frustrated
by the publishers and high prices of the journals they have
been editing, are also trying to follow the open access model.
Here at Emory Drs. Nickerson and Boatright, in the Department
of Opthamalogy, started their own open access peer reviewed
online journal in 1995, Molecular Vision, that is now one
of the top rated journals in the field.
Open access' biggest hurdle is convincing authors that
its journals are (or will be) as prestigious as
its for profit
competitors. With academic careers based on publication
records, authors want to be sure their work appears
in publications
that will move their careers forward. Only by changing
the model of academic publishing as well as the
tenure/promotion
policies at universities and research institutions
can true reform occur.
Other Models
Scholarly societies, who publish journals in many fields,
are also trying to address the crisis in scholarly communication.
Many rely on journal subscriptions to help support their
societies and therefore are trying to develop more efficient
model for their publishing that don't necessarily go so
far as to provide open access.
• The American Anthropological Society (AAA) has recently changed
its publishing model. It has slashed its journal prices
providing online access to all 29 of its journals (and their backfiles)
to its members at no charge beyond membership dues and
making all its titles available to libraries for less than the present
cost of its top five journals. All this will be available
through the AAA's new web portal, Anthrosource, which will
also provide access to things such as datasets and audio
and visual material
What Can You Do??
USE
YOUR INFLUENCE! Scholars and scientists have the power
to change the current situation. Yon are the producers and
major consumers of scholarly information and only through
your influence will change occur.
1) Carefully examine the pricing, copyright, and subscription
licensing agreements of any journal you contribute to as
an author, reviewer or editor.
2)
Examine copyright agreements before publishing and modify
them if possible to ensure your right to use your work
or post it on a public archive. Copyright transfer agreements
often require you to transfer all of your copyrights
exclusively to the publisher, thereby
losing control of any subsequent public distribution
of your work. Restrictions on use of your own work may
prohibit personal
distribution for teaching and research, as well as publicly
posting your paper on publicly available Websites and
archives.
3) Where possible, publish in open access journals which
employ funding models that do not charge
readers
or their institutions for access. Serve on editorial
boards or review manuscripts for open access journals.
(For
a list of open access journals, see the Directory of
Open Access Journals at www.doaj.org.)
4) Encourage your society to explore alternatives to contacting
or selling its publications to a commercial publisher.
5) Start your own open access journal!
More Information
Edwards, Richard and Shulenburger, David, "The High
Cost of Scholarly Journals (and What to Do About It)," Change
Nov/Dec 2003. (N.B. Edwards is the senior vice chancellor
at the University of Nebraska and Shulenburger is executive
vice chancellor at the University of Kansas.)
Zell,
Hans, "The Rise and Rise of Journal Prices in
African Studies, " Africana Libraries Newsletter, June/Sept.
2003, p.7 9
Create
Change: New Systems of Scholarly Communication. http.IA,www.createchange.org
ELECTRONIC UPDATE
New Databases, etc.
Biography
Reference Bank is a comprehensive database of
biographical information on more than one million people
from throughout history, around the world, and across all
disciplines and subject
areas.
Biography
Resource Center combines Gale biographical sources such
as Biography and Genealogy Master Index and
biographies from Marquis Who's Who publications. Full text
articles from about 250 periodicals are also included. CQ
Library has added two new collections:
• CQ
Voting and Elections Collection integrates a wealth of
data, authoritative analyses, concise
explanations,
and historical material on the American voter, major and
minor political parties, campaigns and elections, and historical
and modern races for Congress, the presidency, and governorships.
This research and reference website is organized into six
categories: presidential, congressional and gubernatorial
elections, campaigns, political, parties, and voter demographics.
• CQ Congress Collection provides an analytical survey of the
history and development; powers; personalities; current developments;
and legislation considered and passed by the United States
Congress. A wealth of data with nonbiased commentary is organized
under four sections: public policy, members of Congress,
CQ key votes, and legislative branch background information.
The members and key votes sections allow searching by various
demographic fields.
The
Chronicle of Higher Education is now available campus
wide. You connect to it through EUCLID or the eJournals Web
page.
Communication & Mass
Media Complete
(CMMC) is the result of the merging of two popular communications
databases, CommSearch and Mass Media Articles Index. CMMC
contains the entire Communication & Mass Media Index
(CMMI), plus a full text collection comprised of more than
160 communication and mass media journals.
Education Abstracts is a bibliographic database that indexes
and abstracts articles of at least one column in length from
English language periodicals and yearbooks published in the
United States and elsewhere. English language books relating
to education published in 1995 or later are also indexed.
Religion
Case Reporter is a
digest, cumulative index, and cumulative table of statutes
for Federal
and state cases
addressing the free exercise of religion, state establishment
of religion, the clergy, and religious institutions. January
1998 to date.
Social
Sciences Abstracts is a bibliographic database that
indexes and abstracts articles of at least one column in
length from English language periodicals published in the
United States and elsewhere. Coverage includes a wide range
of interdisciplinary fields covered in a broad array of social
sciences journals.
Ulrich's
International provides data on over 210,000 regularly
published periodicals and irregularly issued serials. Also
includes over 47,000 cessations since 1979. Provides purchasing
and contact information (conventional and electronic) for
over 90,000 publishers in 200 countries.
Cancelled Databases
Several databases we received through Galileo have been dropped
from the system due to state budget woes. Emory's access
to the following ended on December 17'":
- Biological and Agricultural Index
- Book
Review Digest
- General
Science index
- Index
to Legal Periodicals and Books
- Readers
Guide Abstracts
- Wilson
Business Abstracts
Many
of the materials indexes in these databases are available
elsewhere. To locate an alternate source, please contact
your librarian
Trial
Databases
BBC Monitor, apolitical news monitoring division of the BBC
World Service will be on trial in early spring semester.
BBC Monitor is compiled from selected, authoritative, media
in 150 countries. Fulltext English language translations
of foreign media are included. BBC Monitor complements
World News Connection, a similar service produced by the
CIA and currently available to Emory users.
Europa
Online, an electronic version of the standard reference
book providing information on the
history press and statistics
of each country of the world is available on trial until
Feb. 13t".
Research Guides
Don't forget to look over the numerous new research guides
available for you and your students. Research guides provide
an overview of paper and electronic reference resources
in a particular field. Check them out at http://web.library.emory.edu/services/ressvcs/researchguides.html
EDUCATION NEWS
The new year has brought major changes within the U.S. Department
of Education that have the potential to dramatically affect
research in the area of education and related disciplines.
These changes are to be implemented by a new contractor
to be hired by the Department of Education. At this date,
the contractor has yet to be named.
Some of the changes include:
• End
of the ERIC (Education Information Resource
Center) Clearinghouse system. These Clearinghouses
collected
and published documents and served as a research assistance
location via AskERIC. Each had its own web page. One
of their most important functions was in construction
of the ERIC
databases. Some Clearinghouses have moved to new locations.
This information is available at http://www.lib.msu.edu/corby/education/eric~
clearinghouseplans.htm.
• The
ERIC database is not required to be updafedduring the period,lanuary
T and September
30, 2004. New citations
for January 1 August 2004 are to be available by September
30, 2004, with ongoing updating after this date.
• The
new contract requires that the system include documents
in electronic format. It is still
undetermined
if materials in other formats will even be included in the
index.
More
information about this situation is available at http://www.lib.msu.edu/corby/education/doe.htm#official.
The Library is carefully monitoring this situation and
exploring alternatives in order to guarantee that quality
and timely research materials are available to our user community.
Stay tuned for further developments. Please feel free to
contact Barb Mann, Education Liaison (7 0314 libbjm@emory.edu)
with issues and suggestions.
1,2,3,4...
DATA CENTER NEWS
In the Electronic
Data Center, there have been some exciting
developments that will be of interest to the social sciences
community:
New Collections and Resources:
The
Roper Center--the library has purchased a membership subscription
to the Roper Center for Public Opinion Research,
one of the premier polling data institutions in the country.
Membership will give Emory on line access to resources such
as iPoll, which allows users to search through a collection
of nearly 500,000 questions taken from national public opinion
surveys going back to 1935, and Roper's collection of polls
on presidential approval ratings. Emory patrons will also
have access to Roper's vast archive of studies, which cover
politics, sociology, and economics and include the Voter
News Service studies and the General Social Survey series.
Access to the archive, will be limited to 50 datasets/year,
and requests for datasets from the archive must be placed
with the Data Center.
The
International Telecommunications Union World Telecommunications
Indicators--the Data Center now has the latest CD edition
ready for use on its public workstations. The WorldTelecommunications
Indicators contains a wealth of time series data on telecommunications
infrastructure and facilities for all countries in the world.
The database allows patrons to save subsets of data directly
into spreadsheets for programs such as Microsoft Excel.
DataFerrett and Voteview the public workstations in the
Center have recently added two new applications of interest
to social scientists. DataFerrett allows users to extract
data from datasets produced by the Census Bureau such as
the Current Population Surveys series and the American Housing
Survey. Users can download subsets of variables from the
available datasets for use in statistical analysis. Voteview
contains data for all individual roll call votes in the United
States House and Representatives and Senate for the first
106 Congresses (1789 2000). Users can map out distributions
of votes and download data on the votes into a spreadsheet
ready format.
New Staff:
The Data Center has hired Joel
Moore and Rich
Vining to
help with walk in requests and other matters. Joel and Rich
are both third year graduate students in the Political Science
department; Joel's subject area of interest is political
economy in East Asia, while Rich studies judicial politics.
Questions? Contact Dr.
Rob O'Reilly, Director of the Data
Center, at roreill@emory.edu.
BUILDING UPDATES
Matheson Reading Room
Check
out the Matheson Reading Room in Candler Library lately?
Furnishings are almost complete. Each study table
now has two lamps which include network and electrical connections.
Cozy leather sofas and chairs make reading easier and new
floor lamps have been placed on the bridge connecting Candler
to Woodruff. The Matheson Reading Room has proven to be very
popular with users. Statistics indicate that 12,435 patrons
used the space
during the fall semester, an average of 100.28 per day. The
most popular hours are in the afternoon and 8 10 p.m. Matheson
was officially dedicated on December 11th.
Fourth Floor Compact Shelving
Books on the Move! Over 150,000 books with call numbers QA,
QH, QM, QP, QR, T, U, and Z are returning to their renovated
home! The fourth floor has been remodeled to include compact
shelving, new flooring, new and improved lighting and improved
study space. The floor will again be open to patrons beginning
on February 9, 2004.
From
January 26 February 6 use the EUCLID "Request
It" option to get General Libraries' materials classed
in QA-Z. Any requested items will be held for pick up on
the shelves opposite the level 3 Circulation Desk. Also in
February, faculty and graduate students displaced from their
Level 4 studies during construction will be offered
space on the renovated Level 4.
Woodruff
Library Graduate Fellowships Application Deadline March
14, 2004
Funded by the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences the Woodruff
Library will award up to four fellowships for 2004 2005 (9
month or 12month) to advanced graduate students expecting
to complete their dissertations by the end of the fellowship
period. Fellows will work approximately 20 hours per week
in the library in an area relating to their subject specialization.
Library areas hosting fellows may include Special Collections
and Archives, the Lewis H. Beck Center for Electronic Collections
and Services, the Electronic Data Services Center, Collection
Management, Library Systems Division, and others.
Fellows may be assigned to work with curators and specialists
in the various library areas on projects such as preparing
archival collections for research use and developing a seminar
or exhibition from the collection; developing or managing
a digital project in the fellow's subject area; assisting
in research projects with numeric data sets; assisting in
designing data gathering tools and in statistical analysis
of user survey instruments; assisting in analyzing and developing
library collections in a particular subject area; assisting
students with research projects.
Two types of fellowships may be offered: a 12-month fellowship
(September 1, 2004 August 31, 2005) with a stipend of $16,000,
or a 9 month fellowship (September 1, 2004 May 31, 2005)
with stipend of $12,000. Three month fellowships for summer
2005, may also be available.
Some of the social science graduate students who have been
Woodruff Fellows in the past include: Curtis Meeks, Rob O'Reilly,
and Chris Palazzolo of the Political Science Department.
All Fellows agree that this is a wonderful opportunity to
complete your dissertation and build valuable new skills.
Think about applying!
The deadline for applications is 4 p.m. Tuesday, March 16,
2004. For full descriptions of the fellowships and application
information, please visit: http://web.library.emory.edulserviceslhrljobs.ht
ml
DID YOU KNOW? Microform Scanning Capabilities Upgraded
Think Microforms are just for reading and printing? Well,
not anymore! Scanning capability has been added to Reader
#4. Now users can create PDF files from microfiche and microfilm
and save them to a floppy, CD, or Zip disk. Unlike printing,
there is no charge to create PDF files, though users must
provide their own disks. Written instructions are available
at the reader and personal assistance is available from the
Level 1 Infocommons students or by contacting the Reference
Desk. Please direct questions or comments to Elizabeth Hashimoto,
Microforms and Research Services Specialist, 404-727 2322,
ehashim@emory.edu.
Instructional Outreach to First Year students
The Woodruff Library recognizes the unique needs of Emory's
newest students through its instructional outreach program.
Department liaisons who are specialists in their disciplines
contact First Year Seminar professors near the beginning
of each semester to offer a range of library instruction
services. Librarians can provide in class research instruction
to whole classes, design web guides to make library resources
accessible, assist professors with integrating research into
course assignments, and offer one on one research assistance.
To request instructional services for your classes, please
contact Nancy Reinhold at 404 727 0148 or Jennifer Jones
at 404 727 2568.
COMINGS & GOINGS
Four new staff have joined the Woodruff Library to work with
students and faculty in the social sciences:
Liz
Cooper is the new Anthropology Librarian. Liz
comes to Emory after working seven years at the American
University
in Cairo Library, first as the Head of the Library Systems
Department and later as the Electronic Resources and User
Services Librarian. She also spent last year in Bulgaria
working with refugee women from the Middle East. Liz received
her MLIS from the University of Texas at Austin and her MA
in Middle East Studies from the American University in Cairo.
Liz joined the library on October 15. You can reach her
at ecoope2@emory.edu or 7 0115.
Rob
O'Reilly has officially replaced Dr. Joel Herndon as
the library's Coordinator of Electronic Data Services. Rob
started working in the Data Center in December 2000 as one
of the library's first group of Woodruff Fellows and then
stayed on in the Center as a graduate assistant handling
patron request and then as interim manager after Joel left
in June 2003. His tenure as Coordinator began on October
1, 2003. Rob received a Ph.D. from Emory's Political Science
Department in August 2003; his dissertation (soon to be in
the stacks!) was on domestic politics and trade policy and
included intensive qualitative and quantitative analysis.
A portion of his dissertation is currently under review at
Comparative Political Studies. Rob also taught POLS 110 (Introduction
to Politics) and won a Graduate Teaching award from the Political
Science Department in 2002. You can reach Rob at roreill@emory.edu or 7 0129.
Justin
Otto has been appointed as the new Librarian
for Economics, replacing Jana Lonberger who has taken
over U.
S. History. Justin comes to Emory from the Information School
at the University of Washington where he was a graduate reference
assistant in the Foster Business Library and received his
MLIS in June 2003. Justin taught economics at Washington
State University where h received his MA and BA in economics.
Justin has been previously employed as a Licensed Financial
Assistant at KMS Financial Services in Seattle, Washington.
Justin joined the staff on October 13th. You can reach him
at jotto@emory.edu or 7 0150
Chris
Palazzolo has been appointed to serve in a newly created
position, Post Graduate Library Fellow for Political Science.
This is a three year appointment. Chris is an ABD student
in the Emory Political Science Department. He was a Woodruff
Graduate Fellow in the Data Center in 2002 2003 and taught
Introduction to Comparative Politics as a Dean's Teaching
Fellow at Emory in fall 2003. Chris received his BA in International
Studies and French at Rhodes College and his MA in Political
Science at Emory. Chris succeeds Liz McBride as Political
Science Librarian. Liz remains as Librarian for African Studies
and Sociology. You can reach Chris, at cpalazz@emory.edu or 7 0143.
LIBRARY
AND ITD CONTACTS:
General
Libraries
LIAISONS
/LIBRARIANS
Librarians
are assigned to work with individual academic departments.
They acquire research materials in the field and can assist
faculty and students with instruction or research needs.
Librarians also serve a liaison function for their departments
and can provide general information about library news
and services.
Raquel
Cogell 7 0682 rcogell@emory.edu
African American Studies Librarian, Research Services Leader
Liz
Cooper 7 0115 ecoope2@emory.edu
Anthropology Librarian
Barbara
Mann 7 0314 libbjm@emory.edu
Educational Studies, International Documentation Librarian
Liz
McBride 7 6953 libemb@emory.edu
African Studies and Sociology Librarian
Rob
O'Reilly 7 6129 roreill@emory.edu
Coordinator of Electronic Data Services. Oversees electronic data collections
and services. Emory's representative to ICPSR
Justin
Otto 7 0150 jotto@emory.edu
Economics Librarian
Chris
Palazzolo 7 0143 cpalazz@emory.edu
Political Science Librarian
Sala
Rhodes 2 2833 smrhode@emory.edu
Psychology Librarian
Sandra
Still 71061 libsjs@emory.edu
Women's Studies Librarian.
SERVICES
Government Information Center, 7 6880
is main service number.
Interlibrary
Loan Services, Margaret Ellingson, Coordinator.
7 6874 is the main service number. Margaret may be reached
at 7 6893 or libmgw@emory.edu
Reference/Research
Services, Raquel Cogell, Head. 7 6875 is the
main service number. Raquel may be reached at 7 0682
or rcogell@emory.edu.
Reserves,
Chris Baldassari, Reserves Supervisor at 7 6867 or cbaldas@emory.edu.
Studies/Carrels,
Administrative Office, 76861.
Training/Instruction,
Nancy Reinhold, Coordinator, 7 0148 or libngr@emory.edu
ITD
SUPPORT SERVICES
(ANTHROPOLOGY, ECONOMICS, POLITICAL SCIENCE,
PSYCHOLOGY & SOCIOLOGY)
• Darin Melton, Desktop Support, 7 4634
• Keith Sargent, Desktop Support, 7 4634
• Heather Smith, Desktop Support, 7 4634
(EDUCATIONAL
STUDIES)
• Derek Spansy, Desktop Support, 7 8266,
• Kim Culbertson, Desktop Support, 7 8266
|